On June 17, 2022, the Federal Court of Canada issued its judgment in Benjamin Moore & Co v Attorney General of Canada, 2022 FC 923. The case defines a new test for statutory subject matter under the Patent Act as applied to computer-implemented inventions.
The case was an appeal from a decision of the Patent Appeal Board at the Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) in which patent eligibility was denied to two patent applications filed by Benjamin Moore & Co The inventions claimed in the two applications relate to computer-implemented systems and methods for selecting colours based on scientific findings associating certain mathematically determined colour values with human psychophysical responses.
The appeal was argued on behalf of Benjamin Moore & Co by a litigation team at Ridout & Maybee LLP, which is now part of Smart & Biggar, consisting of Matt Norwood, Ben Mak, Abbas Kassam, and Erin Stuart. The Intellectual Property Institute of Canada (IPIC) joined the case as a third-party intervener.
Ultimately, the Court adopted the test for statutory subject matter in computer implemented inventions proposed by IPIC and endorsed by Benjamin Moore & Co. The test requires that CIPO evaluate statutory subject matter during examination of computer-implemented inventions by performing three steps:
1. Purposively construe the claim.
2. Ask whether the construed claim as a whole consists of only a mere scientific principle or abstract theorem, or whether it comprises a practical application that employs a scientific principle or abstract theorem.
3. If the construed claim comprises a practical application, assess the construed claim for the remaining patentability criteria: statutory categories and judicial exclusions, as well as novelty, obviousness, and utility.
The Court ordered the two Benjamin Moore & Co patent applications to be sent back to CIPO for a new determination of patentability under the new test.
Related Publications & Articles
-
Confirmed: delays in first examination of Canadian trademark applications to be reduced substantially
During a recent meeting, the Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) revealed plans for a significant reduction in the first examination of Canadian trademark applications not using the pre-appro...Read More -
Upcoming amendments to the Regulation respecting the language of commerce and business
On June 26, 2024, the Regulation to amend mainly the Regulation respecting the language of commerce and business was published in the Gazette officielle du Québec. This article provides our preliminar...Read More -
Cleaning up the Act: Canada’s new greenwashing laws
On June 20, 2024, certain amendments to Canada’s Competition Act came into force specifically addressing greenwashing, a term often used to describe a deceptive marketing practice where a business or ...Read More